CHICAGO
(Dow Jones)--Ethanol futures prices have rebounded from last
fall's lows on improved market fundamentals, and better
demand prospects should keep them firm in the near term, according
to analysts.
Ethanol
prices rallied on a combination of higher crude oil/gasoline
prices and the passage of new energy bill late last year, said Ron
Oster, alternative energy analyst at Broadpoint Capital in
St. Louis
. Spot month crude oil futures prices have risen sharply from the
$70-a-barrel level last fall to nearly $100, partly on
geo-political concerns, and gasoline prices have followed,
providing underlying support for ethanol Last fall ethanol prices
declined as the fuel additive encountered a "blending
wall," with ethanol supplies outpacing the Renewable Fuels
Standard of 4.7 billion gallons that was required to be blended
into the nation's gasoline supplies. Since trading below
$1.60 a gallon, nearby ethanol futures have moved as high as $2.20
a gallon recently, a gain of 37.5%.
The
energy bill increased the ethanol blending requirement from a
mandate of 5.4 billion gallons in 2008 to 9.0 billion gallons,
effective at the beginning of the year, providing strength for
ethanol prices, said Oster. Although the new energy bill is
positive for prices, demand for ethanol late in 2007 is
responsible for much of the recent increase in prices, said Dave
Wilson, a Morgan Stanley vice president. "The increase in
ethanol prices has been driven by economics," he said. At one
point in November cash gasoline was trading at nearly a 60-cent
premium to ethanol, which encouraged blending companies to step up
their use of ethanol, increasing their profits and supporting
prices. Since then the spread between the two has narrowed to a
20-cent premium,
Wilson
said. Despite the increase in prices since last fall's
weakness, neither analyst expects the price rally to lead to
additional ethanol plant capacity beyond what already has been
announced. Plants that were mothballed last fall are probably not
going to be restarted any time soon, said
Wilson
. Breakpoint Capital's Oster agrees and said that despite
the earlier publicity surrounding the suspension of several plant
construction projects, overall ethanol industry capacity is
expected to increase, with an additional 3.0 billion gallons
coming on line by the end of 2008.
Ethanol
Price Outlook Mixed
Ethanol
will follow the fortunes of crude oil/gasoline prices, with demand
and input prices also determining prices, both analysts said.
Ethanol and gasoline prices are highly correlated, but the corn
product should continue trading at a discount to gasoline, said
Oster. If crude oil/gasoline prices continue to rally, ethanol
prices will continue to firm, he said. Ethanol should benefit from
additional demand for fuel in the upcoming summer driving season,
said
Wilson
. People drive more in the summer than any other part of the year
and that should help support prices, he said.
Ethanol
prices also depend on the value of corn, ethanol's
primary feedstock. Nearby corn futures recently set 12-year highs
and it is "currently in a battle for acreage with
soybeans," said
Wilson
. It depends on what plants are paying for cash corn. If ethanol
plants are buying cash corn at $4.50 a bushel and ethanol is at
$2.15 a gallon, plants may be breaking even but remain cash-flow
positive and will continue to produce. At prices above that level
it will depend on each plant's efficiency and cost
structure, and the price of ethanol, he said. One bushel of corn
produces approximately 2.8 gallons of ethanol. Friday, the U.S.
Department of Agriculture reported lower-than-expected corn
production and stocks, underscoring a tightening supply situation,
with corn rallying sharply on the news. The higher corn prices
will hurt margins but ethanol prices are closely tied to gasoline
prices, not corn. At current prices ethanol companies will
continue to produce ethanol, said Oster. Currently margins are
cash-flow positive, but if corn prices increase enough to force
negative cash margins, there could be some scaled-back production
and additional delays in plant construction, said Wilson. Friday,
CBOT March corn settled 20 cents higher at $4.95 a bushel. Any
move to a recession by the
U.S.
economy would reduce energy demand, putting downward pressure on
gasoline as well as ethanol prices, Oster said. In addition, if
more capacity comes on line quicker than expected, that could also
depress ethanol as underlying supplies increase. Demand from the
southeastern
U.S.
also is expected to be a key determinant for ethanol prices.
Several southeastern states, including Florida, that didn't
blend ethanol into gasoline prior to 2008 due to state regulations
can now do so, said Wilson. Analysts estimate demand from
Florida
and other southeastern states could eventually reach 3.0 billion
gallons. Spot-month February ethanol closed 9 cents higher at
$2.21 a gallon Friday.